I broke this down by decades. Some of them I either coached, played with or watched. I broke it down into three groups. I'm sure I left some out.

Early to Mid 80s
Scott Chamness (Carrol) Played at St.Lawrence
John Neeld (North Penn)
Ron Stone (Springfeild)
Mike McGreggor (GA) Played at Merrimack
Chris Farrell (Springfeild) Played at PSU
Ron Stone (Springfeild)
Bill Railton (Conestoga) Played at Union
Dave Smink (Conestoga) Played at Amherst
Chris Cummings (Conestoga)
Scott Myers (Lower Merion) Played at Colby
Jimmy Moore (WC East) Drafted by Buffalo Sabres

Early to Mid 90s
Brady Kramer (Haverford School) Played at PC
Mike Opdenaker (Malvern) Played at Williams
Pat Bottino (Bishop Eustace?) Played at UNH
Brain Clevanger (WC East) Merrimack?
Peter Naticchione (LaSalle) Played at Nichols
Mike Loftus (LaSalle) Played at Nichols

Mike Lundy (Lower Merion) was one of the purest goal scorers I've ever seen.

Scott Chamness
Greg Arnold

I remember both Chamness brothers, Arnold and a player named Carmen DiGondomenico (sp?). They all played together at Carroll. El Lutz from HHS was also very good.

I second Roman Bussetti
also, if anyone is bored enough to go watch a LaSalle practice you will see that Wally Muehlenbronner still has it.